213. Poetry: On Butterflies
I came across a link to a blog by someone who I am not affiliated with, and was moved by the request to make a yellow paper butterfly to remember Pavel Friedman. It was said on the blog that he wrote the following poem while in the Warsaw Ghetto, but he was actually in the Ghetto of the Terezin Concentration Camp
Terezin was the “model” camp, the sham, the lie, projected to the world to cover up the disgrace of the Nazis. It was billed to the elderly as a “retirement home,” when in fact it was the town of propaganda, hardly a place of perfection and culture, it was a façade for disease and death.
We remember Pavel Friedman at this time of Passover, when we remember those who are oppressed today and those who were oppressed from the beginning of history. He was born in Prague January 1921, sent to Terezin in April 1942, and died in Auschwitz in September 1944.
FACTS & FIGURES ON TEREZIN
* Over 200,000 Passed through Terezin
*Named for Teresa, Mother of JosephII in 1780
*Propagandized as a Retirement Center/Spa
*97,297 Died, 15,000 Children
* Deaths in the Camp: Malnutrition & Disease
* Called Waiting Room for Auschwitz
*Musicians Pavel, Krasa, Ullmann and other deported there.
*Pavel Friedman writes, I never Saw Another Butterfly
*Opera for Children Brundibar performed over 50 Times, decrying Tyranny (see Narice’s post http://philsgal7759.multiply.com/journal/item/211)
* Site of Staged Visit for Red Cross in 1944.
The Butterfly
The last, the very last,
So richly, brightly, dazzlingly yellow.
Perhaps if the sun’s tears would sing
against a white stone. . . .
Such, such a yellow
Is carried lightly ‘way up high.
It went away I’m sure because it wished to
kiss the world good-bye.
For seven weeks I’ve lived in here,
Penned up inside this ghetto.
But I have found what I love here.
The dandelions call to me
And the white chestnut branches in the court.
Only I never saw another butterfly.
That butterfly was the last one.
Butterflies don’t live in here,
in the ghetto.
~Pavel Friedman 4.6.1942
Elizabeth Taylor reads “The Butterfly”
for Pavel Friedman
~Sans Souci
©4/20/08srk
My sister was born in December;
I was 6 years old. And by the summer
when our 1950’s apartment was stifling and my
father was weary from work and heat
my mother sent him on vacation
to the Catskill Mountains. It didn’t matter that she
needed a rest from an infant
and a soon to be second grader.
She sent my dad.
He took me with him.
We went to a place far from the city
where the blaze of summer bounced
off the lake and hit the tree tops;
The Pine Tree Country Club,
a small, run down hotel with an old “casino,”
composed of a gaggle of little bungalows
with saggy wooden cracked painted porches,
each with its very own wasps’ nest glued and nestled under the eaves;
every pair of bungalow couples shared a bathroom.
There was an old black and white television in the casino
and movies were projected on a screen at night.
My father got me a tee shirt; it was white and had
the emblem of a pine tree, raised in faux, dark green velvet
and the words, “Pine Tree Country Club.” It was itchy as all hell.
I had bad allergies. My father opened fragile clear capsules of
teeny little pink and white pills that spilled into a spoon and then
onto my tongue in hopes of helping me to breathe.
We sat by the lake in Adirondack chairs that had probably been there
as long as the hotel—from the ‘20’s? 30’s. Perhaps this had been
a classy retreat for wealthy city dwellers then, but now the working
class was here. Sitting here by the lake, for a week or two, and then it
was back to the reality of work.
My father was a laborer; he packed and lifted huge boxes of
rain coats and shipped them for the Neptune Raincoat Company
on the Lower East Side of Manhattan, grunting in the heat in
his undershirt in a warehouse.
But here, by the lake he was king in his untucked tropical shirt
with the large green leaf pattern.
The lady next door tried in vain to braid my hair to my specifications
and I protested to my father who shushed me as
we slammed the door of the bungalow. We woke the wasps
who were angered and swarmed over my father–
one managed to get a good bite of his bald head.
My father didn’t want to show me he was in pain and scared, but
I sensed it. Someone told him to “put mud on it.”
We went to the lake where the previous day he hid a
garter snake in his tropical shirt pocket and it peed
a yellow puddle of fear. This time it was my father’s turn to be
fearful, but I helped him by putting a mud pie on his head.
During the week of our sojourn
I learned how to play chop sticks on the tinny old casino piano.
I climbed up on a huge bar stool with cracked red leather
and asked the bartender for a ginger ale.
I sat on the toilet and watched my pet fly, “Cookie”
crawl on my arm.
It was the country, this was my version of nature.
One morning I put on my yellow sun dress and after breakfast
we went to the lake. The sun was bright over head
the sky was intensely clear and blue,
minnows bubbled to the top of the murky green water.
I sat in the large lake chair, my legs straight out, and watched
one, two, three, seven, eleven yellow butterflies
flutter onto my dress and latch on; fifteen, twenty two, my
dress was calling to them, like guiding them to a runway
at an airport, thirty four, thirty five…
I was covered in butterflies; small, silky, stubborn, baby-skinned
little creatures that refused to let go as I tried to brush them off
with shrieks and jumps and shakes. I was terrified.
I never knew the intensity of such intimacy before.
I was so lucky.
Adirondack chair
Return to the poetry tour here
Comments from the parallel universe at Yahoo:
What a wonderful image of you in a yellow dress all covered with flutterbys. And the Pavel Friedman poem was so lovely and sad. The combination of the two poems so emotional.
Thanks for hosting and all your kind words, and your beautiful poetry
Tuesday April 22, 2008 – 02:24pm (MDT)
I think Sue you were blessed, in oh so many ways on that vacation. I loved hearing you tell your story it sounded so very endearing to me and you have such a fine voice for story telling. The idea to link Peter’s request into Poetry Wednesday and your personal post is indeed poetry in motion. What better way to continue the butterfly poem written by Pavel Friedman than to bring those who survived along with you in to another decade and into some recovery. It is like using if I may, the analogy of the butterfly returning to you in magnitude so as to now reasure you and others, that those who suffered in evil are now at Peace and those who continue are once again reassured by the timely presence of the Many Yellow Butterflies of the profound exhistance of Godliness and Nature. Passover Blessings To All.
Wednesday April 23, 2008 – 10:34am (WST)
I’m sure there is always more than the obvious meaning to every name – Friedman means “Man of Peace”. I even mentioned butterflies lately and I even thought of change and transmogrification. Seems such a simple thought in the light of everything else. Maybe it’s a need we all have to see what we could do instead but don’t have the means..? Anyways. Slightly sobered up and waiting to start this day. Great post! J. . For seven weeks I’ve lived in here,
Penned up inside this ghetto.
But I have found what I love here.
The dandelions call to me
.
Wednesday April 23, 2008 – 06:03am (CEST)
I am linking this post into mine in yahoo Sue..thank you. “Just living is not enough,” said the butterfly, “one must have sunshine, freedom and a little flower.” ~Hans Christian Anderson
Wednesday April 23, 2008 – 12:18pm (WST)
I am glad you have such happy memories…I love butterflys in any form but i do not like to think of depressing subjects.
Tuesday April 22, 2008 – 11:22pm (PDT)
hi, sans, what a thought the poem–butterfly conveys, an image is created in my mind of a courageous man, fighting death, defying pain, who finds dandellions and the yellowness as his goal to live up his remaining life in the ghetto, what ppl god made and what a poem Pavel Friedman wrote –immortal he becomes –thanx for the share of treasure
Wednesday April 23, 2008 – 06:23pm (NFT)
i am with you at best i could only change my avatar as sorrow strikes and makes my mouth dumb folded i mourn in peace ShankarG
Wednesday April 23, 2008 – 02:59pm (IST)
Beautiful images of precious memories, flying like butterflies in and out of the blooming flower of our consciousness. Thank you again for sharing these poignant and very personal poems.
You wield a fine pen! Your images are so vividly alive. And a great memory you have!
I still sit and watch butterflies, though not in a yellow dress. Is that why I don’t see the yellow ones!
Butterflies are Free! Who was it that said that? I can’t recall at the moment, anyway that’s what I think of when i watch butterflies, they are free….
Speechless.
Tags: poetry, poetry wednesday, 1950’s
strongwilledwoman wrote on Apr 22, ’08
Sans you are one of the most wonderful writers of this century. I do hope you publish sometime. Your story evoked many emotions… from your mothers gift, your father sharing it with you, to the beauty of nature and a scared little girl. You are a beautiful butterfly.
|
starfishred wrote on Apr 22, ’08
a sigh of silence a sigh of sadness not much one can say is there
|
philsgal7759 wrote on Apr 22, ’08
One of the reasons II love butterflies can be summed up in Friedman’s words
I was covered in butterflies; small, silky, stubborn, baby-skinned little creatures that refused to let go as I tried to brush them off with shrieks and jumps and shakes. I was terrified. I never knew the intensity of such intimacy before. To me butterflies are a symbol of hope. That is why his I Never Saw Another Butterfly is so sad. What is life without even the faintest glimmer of hope that it will get better? I don’t know which is worse Sue the ones who were killed right off or the ones that lived for months and years without hope. That butterfly was the last one. Butterflies don’t live in here, in the ghetto. Thank you for this thought provoking poem |
skeezicks1957 wrote on Apr 22, ’08
Very moving Sans. Both your poem and Paul Friedman’s along with the circumstances of both. Thank you for this post. I’m teary eyed in Indiana.
|
mindsnomad wrote on Apr 22, ’08, edited on Apr 22, ’08
While I love reading history, I dislike how we never tend to learn from it, we repeat our mistakes in such predicability with only a new place for oppression to take its place. I want to stay and read and be with what I feel and not cry but to do that I must stay silent.
|
bostonsdandd wrote on Apr 22, ’08
Beautiful! Just beautiful.
My Lord! I wish I had what you had LOL. Seriously, this is breathtaking! You put us there with you with each line. What a wonderful tribute, My Friend. As the tears pour, I can see you surrounded by butterflies and wish it was me! |
sanssouciblogs wrote on Apr 22, ’08
strongwilledwoman said
Sans you are one of the most wonderful writers of this century. I do hope you publish sometime. Your story evoked many emotions… from your mothers gift, your father sharing it with you, to the beauty of nature and a scared little girl. You are a beautiful butterfly. I am so honored and grateful for this beyond incredible comment– Sue |
sanssouciblogs wrote on Apr 22, ’08
ppiccola said
how beautiful and touching. Couldn’t avoid some tears, just to imagine life in there. and your butterflies will always glide in my mind. Thank you for sharing today. Thank YOU, Piccola, please go over to the poetry tour page and grab some matzo ball soup! |
sanssouciblogs wrote on Apr 22, ’08
starfishred said
a sigh of silence a sigh of sadness not much one can say is there A sigh and a hug for you, Heidi! |
sanssouciblogs wrote on Apr 22, ’08
philsgal7759 said
One of the reasons II love butterflies can be summed up in Friedman’s words
Narice, did you recognize your roses on the sign in page? 😉 We’ve sort of been intermeshing our wavelengths…your butterflies flew over. Thanks for your lovely comment. |
sanssouciblogs wrote on Apr 22, ’08
skeezicks1957 said
Very moving Sans. Both your poem and Paul Friedman’s along with the circumstances of both. Thank you for this post. I’m teary eyed in Indiana. I’m touched that you’re touched and so glad you are here. |
sanssouciblogs wrote on Apr 22, ’08
mindsnomad said
While I love reading history, I dislike how we never tend to learn from it, we repeat our mistakes in such predicability with only a new place for oppression to take its place. I want to stay and read and be with what I feel and not cry but to do that I must stay silent. I’m honored that you are here and reading, and that you are moved, Rashmi. |
sanssouciblogs wrote on Apr 22, ’08
bostonsdandd said
Beautiful! Just beautiful. Lori, each week I embrace you and your visits and marvelous comments. Knowing you as a person and as poet has made me so happy, I am grateful. |
danceinsilence wrote on Apr 22, ’08
Liz’s reading was very evoking and a sharp reminder of Terezin. For those of us that were fortunate enough not to live in those times, are actually less fortunate to not understand struggle, sacrifice, and the rare yet occasional beauty rarely found in those dark days. Pavel did, though sad, it is also uplifting.
… and your writing said it all here … “I never knew the intensity of such intimacy before.” You have outdone yourself this time around … makes knowing you all the better. |
sanssouciblogs wrote on Apr 22, ’08
vickieann said
As a young child I read a book that was written about Auschwitz and I don’t remember the title but I do remember the fear it struck in my heart. So sad to not see a butterfly again, to have no hope. Can you imagine life under those circumstances? Didn’t Elizabeth Taylor do a wonderful job reading the poem for that sensitive video? That gets me. And then my poem, written not so many years later, displays the freedom and joy of life’s simple beauties which we often do not appreciate, because we have it all. I was lucky to have parents and to feel secure. Those poor people didn’t have that.
|
sanssouciblogs wrote on Apr 22, ’08
danceinsilence said
Liz’s reading was very evoking and a sharp reminder of Terezin. For those of us that were fortunate enough not to live in those times, are actually less fortunate to not understand struggle, sacrifice, and the rare yet occasional beauty rarely found in those dark days. Pavel did, though sad, it is also uplifting. Oh my Bill, what a wonderful comment. “outid myself”? Gee I am still looking at this and trying to figure out if it “works;” I’ve never written a poem and posted it so quickly, not like me, I was afraid my “well” was going dry. Thanks, Bill. |
Another beautiful, vivid poem of yours, in which the memories jump out of the words like aroused butterflies. Unforgettable images, those stubborn butterflies scaring the little girl, who was, unknowingly, so lucky. Your voice is a perfect sound track, nothing to envy Elizabeth Taylor. All in all, a deep tribute to Pavel Friedman and all the Jewish martyrs in the nazi concentration camps. Gosh, I feel so emotional.
|
danceinsilence wrote on Apr 22, ’08
Darlin` … yer well is overflowing … Huggers 8=)
|
knightstar wrote on Apr 23, ’08, edited on Apr 23, ’08
Wow–your poem is so beautiful. You’ve captured the essence of your experience to share it with us, as if in real time, in such a way as to make us feel we were ALL there, watching.
–M |
sanssouciblogs wrote on Apr 23, ’08
Thank you, sister! xo
|
sanssouciblogs wrote on Apr 23, ’08
Thanks, again my dear Bill!
|
sanssouciblogs wrote on Apr 23, ’08
Oh, thanks–I have a thing for Garrison Keillor! 😉 I guess telling stories is my thing…they are all true.
|
sanssouciblogs wrote on Apr 23, ’08
Big hugs, Belita.
|
sanssouciblogs wrote on Apr 23, ’08
Big hugs to you, too, Donna.
|
sanssouciblogs wrote on Apr 23, ’08, edited on Apr 23, ’08
ifiik said
Please all you wonderful eople, we need you yo somehowe displayyellow paper butterflies, on Monday, 29th April……It is a day away from all known days, just to remember those caught in the Polish ghettos… I hope you will participate in thes display………………………………. Monday the 29th is yellow butterfly day in honor of those lost in the Warsaw Ghetto. Get your avatars ready! |
sanssouciblogs wrote on Apr 23, ’08
Thanks so much Manfred, it’s wonderful to get all this feedback; I must be on the right track. Thanks for the reinforcement.
|
sanssouciblogs wrote on Apr 23, ’08
Thank you my friend Shankarg; I hope you got something from my poem, too.
|
photospoems wrote on Apr 23, ’08, edited on Apr 23, ’08
I’m along with all the above.
San, what I wrote here was inspired by your beautiful words. ______________________________________________________________________ His weary hands, embraced by the love of his daughter The warmth of her mother, tears flowing watching Her young princes grow. Your thoughts of a sister, the love you both shared. The comfort you must of felt, freedom to run with dad Even though, we know, you missed mom. The warmth of summer, flowing through your yellow dress The reflections you see of their soft wings The tropical flavor they saw, on your father’s shirt No competition to the vibrant warmth of your petite soul. Drinking ginger ale from a straw, you smile The sweetness of flavor, comforting your soul A sun dress of yellow taking on skies of blue Warmth from above, kisses your cheeks No longer a little girl, but a woman with a young girl’s heart Adored by the one you love, looking into your eyes You still see the reflection of a young girl’s memory Expressing the love of eyes looking into yours (((Hugs))) Art |
sanssouciblogs wrote on Apr 23, ’08
Thanks, Art! that’s beautiful, how lovely!
|
sanssouciblogs wrote on Apr 23, ’08
Narice, my dear, I so agree, and I think that by releasing the butterfly he was making peace with his own oncoming death.
|
tulipsinspring wrote on Apr 23, ’08
Friedman’s poem hit me like a physical force. It’s amazing how such a simple observation of the loss of beauty can sometimes convey the true horror more than more graphic descriptions. It has left me feeling teary and so depressed. I remember reading a similar account from somebody in Auschwitz, who said that, for so long, all she wanted was to see a single bird. But they never came there. 🙁
Your poem is lovely, with your usual vivid imagery. Combined with Friedman’s it’s especially poignant. I can imagine your terror as the butterflies covered you … but I see now why you were lucky too. Beautiful! For the rest of my life, whenever I see a yellow butterfly, I will think of Friedman. And of you my friend. Thank you for this amazingly touching tribute, and my very best wishes on Passover. Love you! Hugs!!!! |
sweetpotatoqueen wrote on Apr 23, ’08
My dear…there is so much to take here this week. The writings of Pavel humble me. To endure such sadness and still focus on the beauty of life while awaiting death is just remarkable of what miracles live within the human spirit. As usual ,your writing takes me right there to the lake with you and your experience with nature. The two writings combined are indeed a reminder of how the little moments of life should be cherished.I thank you for this!
|
lonewolfwithin wrote on Apr 23, ’08
wow… i dont think i’ve ever felt so many different emotions when reading a post… almost beyond words… thank you for sharing! *hugs* ^..^
|
lauritasita wrote on Apr 25, ’08
What a wonderful poem. The butterflies are a symbol of hope and life. I was too young to remember that vacation that you took with dad. You had some nice memories with him. This was a very enjoyable post. This may be one of your best poems. I love also the Pavel Friedman poem.
|
sanssouciblogs wrote on Apr 27, ’08
Monday, April 28 is yellow butterfly day! |
starfishred wrote on Jan 27, ’09
there are no words to justify a sigh for all those losts ouls who will never see a butterfly remember yes we must or all will be lost
|
lauritasita wrote on Jan 27, ’09
Sorry I’m late – I didn’t realize the poems were down here, oy. I’m glad I read it since I almost posted it too, hee, hee !
|
sugarpiehuny wrote on Jan 27, ’09
I loved “The Butterfly” I was unable to hear Liz’s video or your narration, I don’t know why..unless it’s Ram.. I hope so and not my video card…for I’m starting with Ram! So I’m going to take this machine apart and go get some Ram so I don’t miss anything else..will be back when I’ve completed my task!
Sue, I do so love your writing..the imagery is so wonderful..You memories so vivid… http://sugarpiehuny.multiply.com/journal/item/124/Grace_OMalley_Poetry_Wed |
sugarpiehuny wrote on Jan 27, ’09
I loved “The Butterfly” I was unable to hear Liz’s video or your narration, I don’t know why..unless it’s Ram.. I hope so and not my video card…for I’m starting with Ram! So I’m going to take this machine apart and go get some Ram so I don’t miss anything else..will be back when I’ve completed my task!
Sue, I do so love your writing..the imagery is so wonderful..You memories so vivid… http://sugarpiehuny.multiply.com/journal/item/124/Grace_OMalley_Poetry_Wed |
sugarpiehuny wrote on Jan 27, ’09, edited on Jan 27, ’09
Thank You for your help.. It worked and I loved Liz’s video, but really your reading is so expressive and vivid.. I absolutley love your voice and how you represent your writing.. so beautiful!
|
sanssouciblogs wrote on Jan 27, ’09
sugarpiehuny said
Thank You for your help.. It worked and I loved Liz’s video, but really you reading is so expressive and vivid.. I absolutley love your voice and how you represent your writing.. so beautiful! Thanks, Sugar! I almost missed your comment, it went to a second page. It worked!!?? Yay, it worked! I posted this last spring and thought it fit the day.
|
forgetmenot525 wrote on Jan 28, ’09
this is a very emotional post, your poem is lovely………….you in a yellow dress covered in butterflies, and the Pavel poem is so moving…. thanks for this.
|
sanssouciblogs wrote on Jan 28, ’09
Thanks, very much, Loretta.
|
sanssouciblogs wrote on Apr 28, ’10
Shalom Aleichem!
Bumping up to repost. This poem has been edited for publication. Sorry, the reading is down, thanks to imeem. |
greenwytch wrote on Apr 28, ’10
i am so thankful you chose to repost this……what an amazing experience you had, i felt like i was right there with you! Shalom!
|
Comments
213. Poetry: On Butterflies — No Comments
HTML tags allowed in your comment: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>