The Puzzler: 5/28/23 The New York Times Magazine
NY Times, Sun May 28, 2023 Vowelless Crossword
Evan’s latest puzzle is in The New York Times Magazine, “Vowelless Crossword”
Link to article is here
SUNDAY VARIETY COLUMN
Variety: Vowel-less Crossword
All consonants are welcome in this outrageous challenge by Evan Kalish.
VOWEL-LESS CROSSWORD — This puzzle is the latest installment of a variety grid that comes around roughly once a year. It’s also Evan Kalish’s third such construction and a ton of fun. I am definitely not getting better as a solver, because there are really no developable skills or strategy I can think of that would help me. So it’s more likely that this is a deducible, entertaining set of entries.
There aren’t even any instructions for this puzzle; its title explains it all. Solve each clue and chuck out every A, E, I, O and U in the solution; if you get it right, the remaining letters fit. Each clue comes with a letter count for the full entry — vowels and consonants — in parenthesis. In the case of multiple-word entries, the number of letters per word is given. The grid also follows the rules of a regular crossword puzzle, where every letter appears in two crossing entries. These two assists are critical, at least for me; I think I’d be mystified without either of them.
For example, take 1-Across, “Help for a homeowner who’s away on vacation” (5, 6). The answer is HOUSE SITTER, which jibes with the (5, 6), but the entry is only six letters in length: Write in HSSTTR, representing H(ou)S(e) S(i)TT(e)R.
On to 7-Across, “Doomsayer’s warning” (3, 3, 2, 4). This instantly made me think of an old joke, and I knew the gist of the answer, although I needed a crossing letter at the very end: Is the end “nigh” or “near?” The answer is THNDSNR, or in its complete form, TH(e) (e)ND (i)S N(ea)R. (The “R” in N(ea)R came to me courtesy of 13-Down, “Prime spot for spectators at a boxing match,” or R(i)NGS(i)D(e) S(ea)T.
I found a few areas of resistance, where I either drew a blank or couldn’t decide between two answers. Or both. For example, 43D: “Producer’s opposite,” where my mind got stuck on the producer of a play or movie, rather than on, well, a product. Then, I vacillated between a “customer” and a CONSUMER, or CNSMR. This is where those crossing letters saved me.
There is one crossing, though, that I found especially difficult. It’s in the northwest corner: 14-Across, “Some kitchen implements,” left me overwhelmed with choices; POTATO PEELERS, or PTTPLRS, was pretty far down on the list. Then, I had no idea what 5-Down, “Improper and inexcusable,” could be; the full word runs ten letters in length, but shrinks to just four consonants. This solves to OUTRAGEOUS, or TRGS, a word I’ve used as high praise instead of excoriation for decades; I know its root, but it’s still my habit.
This grid has two 13-letter entries, marvels of engineering and the longest entries so far in Evan Kalish’s vowel-less puzzles. They solve to much longer expressions, and both present challenges. 30-Across, “‘Seems accurate to me’,” is THAT SOUNDS ABOUT RIGHT, or THTSNDSBTRGHT. 34-Across, “Daily issuances on a school’s P.A. system,” stumped me for quite a while; it solves to MORNING ANNOUNCEMENTS, or MRNNGNNNCMENTS, which has almost too many N’s to keep track of. I loved deducing these two entries as the consonants gradually piled up.
A couple of other favorites in this grid include 39-Across, “‘Yada yada’”; its solution in the grid is NDSNNDSN, which took me a couple of beats before I could expand it to AND SO ON AND SO ON. Also, 55-Across, “Something super-awesome, quaintly,” is endearing. I liked THBSKNS, or “the bee’s knees,” but it’s actually THCTSMW, or THE CATS MEOW. Indeed!
See:
I had fun trying
lol I would not even try it!